Sports Goggles

Posts Tagged ‘Super bowl XLII

Spygate: Cracking the J-School 101 Code

leave a comment »

The most interesting portions of all the pre-Super Bowl XLII shows were those in which “Spy-Videogate” was discussed. While the “talent” and ex-NFL players at ESPN, almost to a man, freaked out about the possibility of the New England Patriots taping the St. Louis Rams walk-through before Super Bowl XXXVI, the reactions of the pregame crews of the NFL Network and FOX were vastly different. There was one person at each of the other two networks who appeared to be genuinely offended by the thought of videotaping the Rams’ final on-field maneuvers before Super Bowl game day. At NFLN Adam Schefter, former Denver Post sportswriter and writer and Curt Menefee, the host of FOX’s pregame show.

It made me seriously wonder why and how those men at ESPN banded together and were so vehement in their seeming hate – or extreme dislike – of Bill Belichick and so willing to blindly believe what they heard about the videotaping of the Rams’ walk-through. They appeared to act with a hive mind and speak as one, with each trying almost too hard to trumping the other’s self-righteous stance.

Meanwhile at NFLN Schefter was fixated on the fact the Patriots won each Super Bowl by three points as if it was some sort of magic number while Menefee was going crazy over the lack of concern over the alleged incident by Terry Bradshaw, Howie Long, and Jimmy Johnson.

Trent Dilfer told Schefter that if there was anyone to blame in the incident it was Dick Vermeil for having a final walk-through that was any more than a glorified excuse for the team to get together and expend some energy the day before the game. Dilfer, a Super Bowl-winning quarterback with the Baltimore Ravens, went on to explain that there was no way the Rams’ offensive players were walking through their goal line plays.

On FOX, the ex-players and Johnson, Super Bowl winners all, took turns dispelling any importance on the videotaping of a walk-through, if there was one. However, when it came time for Johnson to talk, illuminating comments spilled forth from the ex-Dallas cowboys and Miami Dolphins head coach’s mouth,

Johnson told Menefee and the nation that one of the producers at FOX witnessed the Rams’ alleged walk-through. He then dropped these bombshells: the Rams did nothing more than drift around the field and gather for a team photo and, no one from the New England Patriots was there videotaping anything.

Menefee replied weakly and posed a hypothetical, what if there was someone would you be angry, question. After Long and Bradshaw laughed at Menefee, the host quickly quieted down and adroitly changed topics.

With all their resources, with Mike Fish and Gregg Easterbrook, NFL specialists John Clayton, Michael Smith and Chris Mortensen pumping up the volume on the importance of former Pats employee, Matt Walsh, who worked in the New England videotaping department, how is it that they all failed to know this information?

Easterbrook went so far as to play the “Journalism 101 card” in his article which acted to castigate anyone he must have felt who is an outsider and is questioning the veracity of ESPN’s reports of New England’s videotaping practices. That Fish and Easterbrook are hot-wired to Walsh, who might have breached his confidentiality agreement by possessing videotapes that are the property of the Patriots organization, and seem ready to stake their reputations on the seemingly shady character, there is ample information to quell the notion that the Patriots engaged in taping a St. Louis Rams walk-through the day before their Super Bowl game against New England.

In the pre-production meeting before NFL Countdown on the Super Bowl XLII Sunday, who met with or talked by phone the Chris Berman, Tom Jackson, Steve Young, and Mike Ditka? How is it possible that no one at ESPN had the information Jimmy Johnson had? NFL Countdown producer Jay Rothman surely had a hand in what information was to be disseminated to the public. But Rothman and/or his assistants probably – and rightfully – leaned on the information provided to them by the reporters covering the alleged taping incident.

At the same time, we were and are left to wonder what Steve Young’s Super Bowl Saturday “walk-through” experiences were. How about Emmitt Smith’s? After all, he played for Jimmy Johnson when the Cowboys won three Super Bowls in the 1990s. How about Ditka? He in played in Super Bowls for legendary Cowboys head coach Tom Landry and was the head coach of the Chicago Bears Super Bowl-winning team. Perhaps they, unlike their peers on other networks lined up in various formations and discussed the execution of given plays; yet it is difficult to imagine Smith did, since he played for Johnson.

It appears that faulty information provided by ESPN journalists allowed for the NFL Countdown crew to tow the line and report the distinct possibility that a New England Patriots staffer – Matt Walsh? – videotaped the St. Louis Rams walk-through the day before their Super Bowl game against the Pats. Through this lens the countenance of Countdown crew can be understood and much of their vehemence toward the Patriots can be absolved.

However, what cannot be absolved is the J-101 lesson readers were treated to at the hand of Easterbrook:

Flash back to September. After the league made its strange decision to destroy the materials, then refused to say what they contained, several media figures, including me, did this Journalism 101 exercise: Current scandal involves current taping by the Patriots. Are there any former Patriots video officials from New England‘s Super Bowl runs? That led to a former New England scout and video department official named Matt Walsh, who now lives in Hawaii. Simultaneously, the NFL grapevine was alive with rumors — caution, rumors — that the Patriots were guilty not just of taping sidelines during games but rather of much more serious transgressions. The primary rumor, which was reported Saturday by the Boston Herald, was that the Patriots secretly taped the St. Louis Rams’ private walk-through before Super Bowl XXXVI, that the Pats knew some of the Rams’ plays and formations in advance.

Saturday morning, the Boston Herald ran a story asserting the Patriots secretly taped the Rams’ private walk-through before Super Bowl XXXVI. The Herald cited an unnamed source and did not name Walsh as the person behind the camera.

Also Saturday, Mike Fish reported on ESPN that St. Louis‘ walk-through was devoted to red zone plays — all new plays and new formations the Rams had not shown during the season. Going into that Super Bowl, the Rams’ “Greatest Show on Turf” was the league’s highest-scoring team. In that game, St. Louis was held to a field goal in the first half. The Rams kept getting bogged down, as if New England knew what plays were coming. If the Patriots secretly taped the Rams’ walk-through, then stopped the red zone plays the Rams showed in that walk-through, then won that Super Bowl by three points, then logic says New England materially benefited from cheating in the Super Bowl. If true, this would be the worst sports scandal since the Black Sox.

Let’s put that in capital letters: IF TRUE. We don’t yet know whether the Super Bowl allegations are true. Then again, we are into only the second day of information going on the record and the league finally answering some questions about the subject.

The words scream out, ‘the worst scandal since the Chicago Black Sox!’ And these are preceded by the ominous-sounding:

“The Rams kept getting bogged down, as if New England knew what plays were coming.”

Be afraid of the hoodie, be very afraid; the boogie man cometh.

The words scream out, ‘Journalism 101’, if you didn’t take it, no one wants to hear a peep from you, your voice does not count.

I wonder if Jimmy Johnson took Journalism 101 long, long ago at the University of Arkansas because he seems to have remembered more from his class than either Easterbrook or Fish. Then again, isn’t investigative reporting an art unto itself?

Either way, with Jimmy Johnson’s divulging that the Rams did not walk through their goal line offense plays, that they had no walk-through at all, makes one think that J-101 isn’t all it’s cracked up to be.


Bill Belichick: The Mystery of The Hoodie

with 33 comments

belichickhoodie1.jpgBill Belichick is giving the press nothing. Nada. Not an inch. And I, for one, love it. Mike Greenberg on the Mike and Mike in the Morning show is “flabbergasted” over the Patriots head coach’s ability to give so little of himself to the press. Greenberg said things like, I have never seen anyone who has is so guarded in the public, who we don’t know.

Greenberg stated that he was not being critical of Belichick, he is simply flummoxed that the coach has the singular ability to keep his emotions in check while in the public eye. Here are some selected Belichick quotes from yesterday:

“It takes a lot to get to this point, but we’re starting all over in the new ’08 season and it’s already time to move on. We’re already into the offseason and that’s just the way it is. So, we’ll start moving ahead towards next year.”…

Read the rest of this entry »

Quick Notes: Terrelle Pryor Update; Stay Classy, NYG; Seahawks and the Rooney Rule; UConn Upset; Nat’l Signing Day; Pinstripes for Clemens?; Shaq Fact; Vegas Loses on SB XLII

with 43 comments

pryor.jpgTerrelle Pryor update

The number one high school football player in the country, Terrelle Pryor (pictured at right) of Jeannette High School in Jeanette, Pensylvania said simply that he is not making a decision on a college at the moment. Pryor, a 6’6″, 207-pound quarterback also said that because he led his team to a state championship and was playing basketball two days later, he needed more time to make a decision. Beyond his head coach Ray Reitz, Pryor has also had the benefit of consultation with Pittsburgh Steelers QB, Charlie Batch.

Read the rest of this entry »

Super Bowl XLII: Giants Win 17-14 on Final Drive By Manning and Company

with 55 comments


The adage is, “You are what you are.” In the NFL it is, “You are what your record says you are.” The New York Giants are the 5th-most penalized team in the NFL, yet for over 32 minutes committed no penalties, and only two, delay of game and illegal batting for over 45 minutes. They got away with blows to Tom Brady’s head (Kawika Mitchell), illegal contact on receivers numerous times (the most obvious being Sam Madison on a key 3rd down play on Wes Welker, pass interference on the same play (Madison had his right arm firmly placed around Welker’s neck before the ball arrived).

The play that set up the winning touchdown was a blatant pick play allowing Steve Smith to run free for 10 yards before any Patriot player came into camera view. Any one of those penalties alters the entire tenor of Super Bowl XLII.

Read the rest of this entry »

Super Bowl XLII: And the Winner Is…

with 6 comments

belichick.jpgThe question of the last two weeks is, who will win Super Bowl XLII, the New England Patriots or the New York Giants? There’s so much to consider. You can get deep into the stats, deep into the matchups, deep into trends, deep into team against comparisons; deep into any or all of a long list of “indicators.”

I’m going to take what I consider to be the most important aspects of the game and toss them out and feel how I feel about them as they come to me. And then I’ll tell you who will win. Let’s see what happens…

New England defeated New York in the final game of the exhibition season. The Patriots defeated the Giants in Week 17. Now the two play in the Super Bowl. Many people expected the Pats to be here. Very few people outside of the G-men faithful expected them to be here. The Patriots arrive undefeated but to some, they are not playing their best football. The Giants, though, arrive at or near their peak. But is that really true?

Read the rest of this entry »

Spygate: There’s Something Fishy Going On

with 14 comments

trophyhelmets.jpgThis piece began as an innocuous update on what was known as “Videogate” and has now, by ESPN, been turned into “Spygate.” As the update was being written, new news broke and with it came a revelation, of sorts.

First, I want to ask people to use the original name, “Videogate” instead of “Spygate” which is way too obvious and far too sensationalistic. That subtle and unnoticed name change has subtly acted to alter the way the incident is being viewed. It is now more nefarious, more sinister. It implies that we need to dig deep into the rabbit hole that is Bill Belichick’s NFL and find him to be the holder of secrets on the order of ———– the CIA.

Believe that only if you need to….

Read the rest of this entry »

Destruction of Patriots Tapes Set for Congress: Goodell to Testify

with 34 comments

spectorgoodell.jpgArlen Spector, Republican senator from Pennsylvania and ranking Republican on the Senate Judiciary Committee, has called Roger Goodell in front of the committee to address the destruction of the tapes that revealed spying by the New England Patriots:

“That requires an explanation,” Specter said. “The N.F.L. has a very preferred status in our country with their antitrust exemption. The American people are entitled to be sure about the integrity of the game. It’s analogous to the C.I.A. destruction of tapes. Or any time you have records destroyed.”…

Joe Browne, the N.F.L.’s executive vice president for internal affairs, said, “The irony is that we have been in contact with the senator’s office several times in recent weeks.” He added that “the issue of these letters was not discussed.”

Read the rest of this entry »